| Platinum | Judge and Jury |
| Gold | Jake's Grill & Oyster House |
| Silver | Studebaker Pub and Diner |
| Bronze | Gator Ted's Tap & Grill |
| Top Pick | Jacksons Landing Bar Grill Hub Restaurant |
| Top Pick | QB Sports Bar Grill Games |
| Top Pick | Rose Garden Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Shoeless Joe's Sports Grill - Brant St |
| Top Pick | Skyway Diner |
| Top Pick | Wimpy's Diner |