| Platinum | Son of a Peach |
| Gold | Mount Royal Pizza |
| Silver | Artisan Pizza |
| Bronze | Right Wingers |
| Top Pick | Applestone Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | City Pizza |
| Top Pick | Fortinos |
| Top Pick | Lugano 2 For 1 Pizza |
| Top Pick | Papa John's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Tezgah Gourmet Burgers & Wood Fire Pizza |